Blog
FAILURE TO RECOGNIZE DUTY TO DISCLOSE FAVORABLE EVIDENCE WITHOUT REGARD TO MATERIALITY HAUNTS COURTS
U.S Court of Appeals Doubts that Prosecutors Promise Favorable Treatment as a Reward for Testifying…Really?!?
By: Houston Criminal Lawyer John Floyd and Paralegal Billy Sinclair
The U.S. Supreme Court in a 1963 landmark decision, Brady v. Maryland, held that, as a matter of due process, prosecutors in criminal cases have a duty to disclose evidence favorable to a defendant upon request provided the evidence is material to either guilt or punishment. What constitutes “material” evidence has long been a source of legal confusion and disharmony within the justice system, notwithstanding the Supreme Court’s attempt in United States v. Bagley in 1985 to defines materiality; specifically, favorable evidence is material if there is a “reasonable probability” that its disclosure prior to trial would have changed the outcome of the proceedings.
Thus, the definition of “materiality” became the subject of post-conviction inquiry and gave prosecutors cover when they withheld or concealed favorable evidence before trial. Prosecutors who intentionally hide favorable evidence know they will have the opportunity in post-conviction proceedings to simply argue that disclosure of the evidence would not have changed the outcome of either the verdict or punishment. They can argue the prosecution presented sufficient evidence independent of the suppressed favorable evidence to sustain both conviction and sentence, rendering Brady’s duty to disclose practically meaningless.
In the wake of Brady and its progeny, the American Bar Association, and the bar associations in 49 states, have adopted Rule 3.8(d) of the Model Rules of Professional Conduct that mandates disclosure of either exculpatory or mitigating evidence prior to trial without regard to materiality. The problem with Rule 3.8(d) is that it does not have the force of law. It is an ethical rule subject only to the jurisdiction and supervision of state bar associations—groups that do not have either the professional inclination or courage to discipline prosecutors who withhold or conceal favorable evidence, regardless of any post-conviction determination of its materiality.
In 2011, we posted a piece about the Supreme Court’s decision to hear a Louisiana murder case (Smith v. Cain) involving egregious suppression of favorable evidence. The American Bar Association filed an amicus curiae brief in the Smith case urging the Supreme Court to adopt Rule 3.8(d)’s broader duty to disclose favorable evidence independent of the “materiality” assessment required by Bagley. The ABA argued that Rule 3.8(d) required prosecutors as a matter of legal and ethical duty to disclose all favorable evidence regardless of its materiality and urged the Court to “recognize” this seemingly logical position. In 2012, we posted a follow up piece about the Supreme Court decision in which the court reversed Smith’s conviction but refused to even mention Rule 3.8(d), much less address its legal merits as suggested by the ABA. Several months later, we posted yet another piece about how Smith and other Supreme Court decisions, that prevented professional and personal accountability for intentionally hiding favorable evidence, have the effect of encouraging prosecutorial misconduct.
A recent decision (March 7, 2013) by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in Grant v. Lockett perfectly illustrates our concerns about the impact of Smith.
The core facts of Taibu Grant’s case are: On January 8, 1997, Keith Gilliam was gunned down outside the Where It’s At Bar in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Gilliam and his wife had been at the bar after work for a couple hours before deciding to leave around midnight. As he was walking toward his vehicle, Gilliam was approached by a lone gunman on foot who opened fire on Gilliam killing him and wounding another person named Leroy Butler. About five minutes later, a maroon Buick drove by the bar and the occupants opened fire, wounding two other people standing in front of the bar. The police subsequently recovered fifteen shell cases, four bullets, and bullet fragments in the street at the intersection of Lincoln and Lemington Avenues, where the bar was located. A forensic analysis determined that all the bullets were fired from the same gun—a weapon never found by the police. Thus, the gunman who killed Gilliam and wounded Butler probably was the same gunman in the maroon Buick who wounded the other two bystanders.
Besides Butler, there were three other witnesses (Gerald Bonners, Kim Oden and Mark Gee) at the scene, where Gilliam was killed and Butler wounded, who informed authorities that Grant was not the shooter. And, finally, two latent fingerprints found in the stolen Buick did not match Grant’s prints.
The police, however, found a witness named Christopher Moore who lived in an apartment about 250 feet from the bar. He informed the authorities that he was leaving his apartment when he heard some shots coming from a parking lot of a food mart located directly across the street from the bar. He saw a man dressed in a blue, hooded coat with what appeared to be a lighter blue horizontal stripe on it. He said he saw the shooter for only a few moments before he disappeared. But, a few minutes later, Moore saw a man he identified as Grant wearing the same clothing as the shooter in the food mart parking lot. He said he heard Grant yell, “I had to let loose of them niggers,” to someone standing nearby.
The problem with Christopher Moore is that he carried some heavy criminal baggage. He had two burglary convictions and a theft conviction in 1983 as well as two drug convictions in 1993. In fact, Moore was still on parole for one of the drug convictions at the time of Gilliam’s shooting death and when he testified at Grant’s trial. He had also been in the Where It’s At Bar on the night of the shooting—a violation of the conditions of his parole.
Another prosecution witness named Robert Gilbert testified he was heading to, and was near, the bar when he saw Grant walking towards him in a light blue North Carolina jacket. Gilbert’s testimony did not actually link Grant to the shooting incident. The prosecution called two other witnesses: Leo Butler, who testified he was wounded by the first shooter as he stood under a stoplight by Lincoln and Lemington Avenues, and who said Grant was not the shooter; and Gerald Bonner who testified he was standing in front of the bar talking to Butler when Gilliam was shot, and like Butler, he said the shooter was not Grant.
In post-conviction applications presented at both the state and federal level, Taibu Grant claimed the prosecution engaged in misconduct because (1) it did not disclose Moore’s criminal history and parole status prior to trial and (2) it agreed to help Moore with his parole violation charge in exchange for the parolee’s testimony against him. In the alternative, Grant claimed he received ineffective assistance of counsel because defense counsel (1) did not exercise due diligence in discovering Moore’s criminal and parole history—all of which were in the records of the Clerk of Court’s office—and (2) did not call Oden or Gee as witnesses.
The state courts denied Grant’s post-conviction applications under two theories: First, the courts denied the Brady/prosecutorial misconduct claim, pointing (1) to defense counsel’s lack of due diligence in discovering the Brady evidence; and (2) the state was not required to disclose Brady evidence in a defendant’s possession or which he could have obtained with the exercise of due diligence. Second, the court denied the ineffective assistance claim, pointing (1) to Grant’s failure to offer any evidence that Moore was on parole either at the time of the crime or when he testified against Grant; and (2) to Grant’s failure to offer evidence that Moore had actually received favorable treatment in exchange for his testimony against Grant.
The U.S. District Court adopted the state courts’ factual findings and legal conclusions concerning both the Brady-related and ineffective assistance claims. The district court supplemented its findings by saying defense counsel’s failure to call Oden and Gee as witnesses was excusable since their testimony would have been “cumulative” to Butler’s and Gilbert’s testimony. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to hear Grant’s case, and elected to reverse his conviction on the basis of the ineffective assistance of counsel claim.
The appeals court was perturbed that both the state courts and federal district court had adopted the factual conclusion that Grant had failed to offer any evidence about Moore’s criminal history when, in fact, “ … the criminal docket sheet and a number of other court documents associated with Moore’s 1993 drug convictions were incorporated into the certified record through two [state] court orders granting [Grant] leave to supplement the record. The docket sheet in the supplemental record … states that Moore was sentenced to three to six years imprisonment for the convictions at issue, effective August 14, 1992 … Thus, it is beyond dispute that the state record supported Grant’s claim that, since Moore was not still in prison at the time of the shooting and Grant’s trial in 1997, Moore was on parole during that period.”
With regard to the second prong of Grant’s ineffective assistance claim (the alleged deal between the prosecution and Moore), the appeals court found that “ … a key prosecution witness’s prior criminal history and resultant parole status clearly constitute important impeachment evidence. It is beyond the range of professionally reasonable judgment to forego investigation of, and impeachment based upon, such evidence absent some apparent strategic reason that might explain or excuse counsel’s failure.”
Thus, and unfortunately predictable, the issue of whether the prosecution deliberately withheld material Brady evidence about Moore’s criminal history/parole status or made a deal with the parolee to help him with his parole status in exchange for his testimony against Grant was not explored. The appeals court, however, in a footnote observation said: “We do not suggest that the prosecutor made any offer of special treatment to Moore in exchange for his testimony. However, we do suggest that requiring evidence of such an agreement is as unrealistic as it is unreasonable. We doubt that any experienced prosecutor would be so naïve as to expressly promise a witness favorable treatment as a reward for testifying against a defendant at trial. The prosecutor would know that any such promise could be fatal to the witness’s credibility upon cross examination by even a modestly competent defense attorney. Although Moore testified he had such an agreement in his [post-trial] affidavit, we will not attribute such tactics to a prosecutor absent more evidence than appears here … that is not the point. The poison lurks in the bias that can arise from the witness’s subjective state of mind, regardless of whether the witness’s belief arose from an actual agreement with, or representation of, the prosecutor.”
The decision by the Third Circuit did not make an explicit finding that the prosecution had in its possession, and withheld it from defense counsel, Moore’s criminal history and parole status. The appeals court dodged this issue by laying all the blame at the office door of defense counsel. And, as for the alleged favorable deal in exchange for testimony, the appeals court was, we believe, disingenuous with its expressed “doubt” that an experienced prosecutor would engage in such conduct when, in fact, the practice is a significant, if not integral, component in the “plea bargaining” process throughout the nation’s criminal justice system. We know, and understand, career criminals like Christopher Moore: they do not testify for the prosecution because they are law-abiding citizens willing to perform their civic responsibility to prevent crime. Criminals testify primarily for one reason, to get a benefit for themselves.
We do not know if Taibu Grant is guilty or not. The only eyewitness against him was an unreliable drug user/parole violator. We do not believe any criminal conviction should stand, much less a person having to spend the rest of his/her life in prison, based on testimony from such a career criminal.
The tragedy in a case like Grant’s is this: had the Supreme Court in Smith v. Cain gave Rule 3.8(d) legal force, or, at least raised it to the level of recognized ethical duty, a defendant’s guilt or innocence would be more clearly established because the jury would know about a witness’s criminal history/parole status and any “deal” he made with the prosecution. The prosecutor in such a case would have a binding ethical duty to disclose this kind of information without regard to its materiality, which is obviously seen through the jaded eye of the prosecutor. In other words, the issue of materiality would be decided by the jury, not by the prosecution. And last, but not least, the courts of appeals wouldn’t have to continually give disingenuous lip service to the purity of a prosecutor’s motives just to justify a conviction.
By: Houston Criminal Lawyer John Floyd and Paralegal Billy Sinclair
John Floyd is Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization
Take the first step toward protecting your freedom by contacting us now
Testimonials
John T. Floyd Law Firm
3730 Kirby Drive # 750, Houston
-
If you have hired attorneys that meet the Webster dictionary definition, ie: "Attorney " is a person that has a law degree, will not be totally honest, can take your money … More and not earn it, will put you off until he is ready to talk to you, and/or never study your case to be able to defend you. Mr. Floyd is the only attorney that doesn't fit that definition!! You will be delighted to have Mr. John Floyd in your corner! Not one attorney that I have ever met that would ever return a check that I sent to him, because he said I paid him too much! Wow! That right there should tell you something about his integrity!!!!! He has a very calm demeanor and doesn't stretch the truth even if you don't want to hear it, he will tell you the truth. Call and set up an appointment with him and judge for yourself. You are wasting time and money on any other attorney, just hire the best, Mr. Floyd.
-
John T. Floyd and his team are some of the best people! I was able to get a second opinion from them on legal advice. His team has been honest, kind, and very informative which has … More been a huge blesssing.
-
I highly recommend John T. Floyd Lawfirm. They are truly knowledgeable and willing to go the extra mile to defend your innocence. Psalms 35
-
Outstanding!Professional knowledge. Rich experiences. Good outcome.
-
-
The best lawyer I ever encounter with a very good personality. He’s very professional and he will go far and beyond for his clients best interest. He’s definitely a 5 star attorney … More when it comes to delivering. I couldn’t be more happier that I hired him !! 👏👏👏👏
-
-
I can honestly say from what I have seen so far, Floyd is a compassionate soul who cares for his client's. Floyd is by far very knowledgeable in this area. He's currently … More assisting my [Father] on a sex assault. We are all suffering so much as my father is an elder man, but we have faith in God, and Mr. Floyd he can dismissed this outrageous allegation soon. Thank you, yoli
-
I had wonderful experience with this law firm. They were so helpful and knowledgeable of the process.my case was dismissed because of Mr John T Floyd,thank you for everything .
-
I am very happy today my case dismissed God bless Mr John T Floyd very good lawyer thanks you so mush sir
-
I had a great experience with this Law Firm, the kind staff helped me locate a Lawyer even though they were unable to take my case.
They were very helpful, kind and returned my call … More in a timely manner. I would definitely recommend them and use them in the future. -
I can tell that Jone is an excellent attorney in Houston. Personally, he is a great man. In addition to great service and amazing results. Recommended
-
Mr. Floyd is an incredible attorney and human being. He cares about your case, the facts, the law, and your life! I am sorry for whatever situation you are going through, but choosing … More Mr. Floyd, his firm, and their professional experience to help you, will be the best decision you ever make!
-
John T Floyd is a straight shooter! He was very direct and responsive to my phone calls and questions. I was in awe of his knowledge, and professional decorum! The best decision that … More you could make is to schedule a consultation with him before considering anyone else!
-
I asked the Law Office of John T. Floyd a very important question regarding the legal aspects of purchasing a firearm with a deferred adjudication charge. They answered the question … More very professionally and accurately and I was quite pleased with the information that was shared. I recommend this law firm because they are very honest and will work for you and with you.
-
I’ve never been one to write reviews but this time I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to say something. I had some serious legal questions I needed answers to concerning Texas laws. … More Being I’m from another state, I found and reached out to Attorney John Floyd for the answers. Mr Floyd listened to to my requests and told me what he need from me and went out of his way to get me the answers. Very polite, straightforward and professional, I can’t thank him enough for all he’s done. Whatever your legal case may be, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Mr Floyd.
-
John & Chris helped my family member get a reduced charge and acceptable plea agreement in place. Their compassion, attention to every detail was what helped carry the day.Truly … More the best of the best.P
-
Mr. Floyd is both ethical and loyal to his clients; two qualities that are hard to find specially in lawyers. I'd definitely recommend him to anyone.Positive
Professionalism …More … More -
Mr. John was very helpful and truly was the reason why my case was dismissed. Thank you so much Mr. John I truly recommend everyone in need to work with him.
-
His service to the community and diligence to helping his clients speaks for its self! Not to mention the many articles, papers and TV appearances that speak to his intellect
-
John has given Excellent service and have been very friendly and extremely helpful to us. I highly recommend this law firm
-
This law firm is diligent, responsive and succeeded in getting my case dismissed. 10/10 would recommend.
-
super knowledgeable, good attitude, would definitely recommend him
-
Very helpful, knowledgeable and honest.
-
John is an amazing person and lawyer who is actually very understanding of how anxious I got and although it was hard to reach him sometimes because of his schedule, but never worry … More he is on top of things. He is very organized, very smart. I had the experience to go through a trial with him, and he always plans ahead well and is actually open and receptive to any ideas and comments I had and he was quick to decide which is right to use at the moment. I really appreciated working with him and Chris. Great lawyers and great people. As I was reminded by John, I am adding that the Jury reached a not guilty decision on the original charge and on a lesser charge in just 25 minutes. It took more time to write the charge and instructions for the jury than it took them to reach a decision.
-
Highly recommend John T Floyd law firm, great response time and demeanor.I was researching an on-going criminal case, when I found an informative article written by John Floyd (about … More the perils of expert testimony). I called his office, and was very pleased to receive a timely call back. Not only was Mr. Floyd candid and helpful, but he had the kindest demeanor of any attorney that I've dealt with. I am so glad to have found this firm.
-
Although I am not a client, John Floyd contacted me the same day I sent an email requesting advice, answered my questions and even when further to assist with my issue and communicated … More with me the next day. A true credit to his profession and I can only imagine how well he provides services to his actual clients!
-
I give Mr. Floyd 10 Stars if they were available so I'm giving him five that's all that's available. The first time I left a message for him it was on a Friday after … More 5 p.m. and within 15 minutes he called me back I told him I needed to buy a lotto ticket because that has never happened. I knew from our chat and him calling me back that he was different from any attorney I've tried to talk to left messages never got called back they didn't even know what I needed and neither did Mr. Floyd but he did call me back. I was very interested in meeting with mr. Floyd about my case because I felt he was very transparent honest and genuine. If you've ever dealt with attorneys they don't have those traits but Mr. Floyd does. He was very honest with me told me what I could and could not do with my case. He is not egotistical he's very compassionate and he actually reads the documents you sent him unbelievable that's never happened. He will be the only lawyer I refer to anyone that needs his expertise. If you're in need of a criminal defense attorney please give John T Floyd a call you will not be disappointed.
-
Mr John is a great human being and a very knowledgeable attorney. He has always called me back promptly,advised me very clearly and never rushed our conversation. i was wrongfully accused … More and Mr John had my case DISMISSED!! on the day of trial after fighting for me for two years. I am very thankful to the John T. Floyd Law Firm. You will not go wrong with John. Mr John you deserve way more then 5 stars.Thank youShaikh.
-
John Floyd Law Firm is highly recommended for your legal needs. He and his staff are highly professional in every aspect. Easy and comfortable feeling talking with him, and he understands … More your needs and explains your legal advice in a way you can understand. Enough just cant be said. Thank You Sir.Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
John was kind enough to assist me with legal advise on my firearm gun rights restoration. I highly recommend him and his firm. Very professional and knowledgeable. If I need assistance … More in the future I will definitely go back to him.
-
What I liked the most was that he actually returned my phone after leaving a message unlike pretty much everyone else I called prior. He listened and answered my question with the best … More advice that would benefit me the most. I was actually lost from moving to Texas from a different state we’re laws vary and he pointed me toward the right direction to get a understanding of if I need to do business with him now or after I contact a lawyer in my home state.
-
John T Floyd handled my sons case & got a dismissal for us! He is great to work with, gets back to you promptly & knows what he’s doing. Definitely one of the best we have had … More to deal with!Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
John is honestly the best! The whole team is. He answered me in a timely manner and helped me when my friend was going through a situation in Houston, Texas as an inmate. He was so … More thorough, honest, and without charging me sent me so much information because I was out of the loop. He never once tried to take you for your money, he did all that he could to. help me and I can't thank him enough.
-
I have used John on two occasions and found him to have full knowledge of Texas law, diligent, creative in plan, and aggressive in defense. He is the best criminal defense attorney … More in the State of Texas. No reason to look elsewhere.
-
I have been calling to get some legal advice pertaining to gun rights. A few legal offices would not even take my call because quote " your not a client and Im losing money. … More I I called John T. Floyd Law Firm and they were not only able to answer my question, but gave great detail information, and further elaborated on their answer. I hope I do not have to use them in the future, but if I do need to, they will be my first call.
-
Great lawyer! Needed some advice and gave me a Consultation, and advice for steps to take, without any hassle l, Was a honest guy and actually wanted to help me and not just take my … More money! Highly recommend!!Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
Attorney Floyd replied very timely to my inquiry and he provided practical advice. I will not hesitate to contact him in the future if I need additional legal counsel.
-
Highly recommend, down to earth lawyer. Talked to me about my legal issues without being super money hungry and genuinely wanted to help me with my legal problems. 5 stars ⭐️.
-
Very knowledgeable and professional. I called and left a message Friday morning and before end of business that day I received a call back.Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism … More …More -
Very helpful highly recommended for any Question / case will definitely keep he's name and number for any other legal advice
-
Excellent service and a lawyer that doesn't lie. He does what he says. JW recommends him.
-
One of the best services Ive used in awhile. Thank you for all the help and answers. You got my life back. Thank youPositive
Quality …More -
Im impressed. This guy was polite and professional and most important...he listened.
-
Good experience and very good lawyer
-
-
-
Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, ValueMore -
It was a pleasure speaking with John. He is knowledgeable and has a true desire to help the people of society. I turned to him for some guidance of a long-standing issue. He never … More rushed our conversation and went out of his way to look into the details to provide the right answer as well as assist me anyway he could. Thank you for our conversations and I wish your and your firm the best. If you need a lawyer, John Floyd is your guy!
-
John represented me in court for roughly 2 years. I won't (and shouldn't) get into any serious details, but let me tell you that I couldn't have chosen anyone better. … More Seriously.Every appearance in court I felt very comfortable. The judge and DA's had a high regard for his reputation. There is a time I recall where simply his presence greatly impacted the court's interpretation of my case and persons. We were in front of the stand and the judge could not stop talking about John's prestige and past accomplishments and how that took in relation to my case. I kept silent in front of the judge, but I observed then that John's popularity and reputation within the court had already given me a better looking rapport with the judge. Let me tell you, I never had more confidence then, knowing that the judge held him in such high regard.This is not to mention how personable John is. I'll be honest that during the stress of court, sharing a laugh with your lawyer helps a lot. This may sound a lot, but I really appreciated the relationship we had then. This is also not to mention that he was able to deal very well with any DA that rotated over the years. Seriously, John was great, prompt with information and very hands on with my case. I had great peace those 2 years until everything wrapped up.If you're looking for a lawyer, I highly, HIGHLY recommend the John T. Floyd Law Firm. He IS nationally renowned, you know. He'll get the job done to the utmost confidence. He's very experienced and has a great record to boot. I am glad to have had him represent me in court and trust me that I never thought I'd ever say that (and whoever does?). We explored every avenue of victory together and I personally enjoyed the experience, despite the seriousness of the accusation.If you have a case that needs to be represented at the highest levels, choose John T. Floyd. He's a good man and very good at what he does. Him and his team has the experience you need to make the best decisions and options to get the best outcome for your case. We got the best result I could possibly ask for, thank God.Seriously. Hire John. He knows what he's doing.Seriously.
-
One of the few honest lawyers I have ever talked to. His complimentary consultation was knowledgeable and thorough. He knew exactly what the issue was and how to handle it. His candid … More appraisal of the situation and how to proceed saved me thousands of dollars in legal fees. If you have a case requiring expertise in John's area of practice, look no further. Hire this man!
-
I had the opportunity to read an article that Mr. Floyd wrote and it was very interesting. I called him about the article and advice concerning a similar situation. He not only gave … More me excellent advice, he pointed out not just what I wanted to hear but what I needed to hear concerning my situation. The Good, The Bad and The ugly in a manner or speaking. He spoke with an open and honest heart with information to help me and not just to get a client.
-
If you are in trouble and need a lawyer, contact the John T. Floyd law firm. Some of the best lawyers in Texas work there! Understanding and helpful lawyers and staff that will do all … More they can to help you 😊
-
He gave me one of the most honest answers I have received in a very long time about any issue I was having with anything. Legal or not legal. I highly recommend giving him a call and … More will be referring him to friends and family if they have any issues in the future.Positive
Responsiveness, Professionalism …More -
He took time out of his day to answer my legal questions and didn’t even charge me. I would definitely recommend him to you.
-
Gave free consultation on getting gun rights back. He truly cares about gun rights and getting you the help you deserve. 100% worth a callPositive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, … More Value …More -
Very professional, great quality work, and very friendly and helpful. Overall, their service is phenomenal. I recommend Mr. Floyd to anyone.
-
Mr. Floyd took the time to explain his experience with the law to me in layman's terms. Definitely give him a call.Positive
Responsiveness, Professionalism …More -
He was honest , knowledgeable , and professional about what we talked about. Most lawyers are just about the money , but not john.Positive
Professionalism …More -
He was very truthful and honest with us very great man I would recommend him and we would use him again
-
Very professional honest and works hard currently working my husband’s appeal I pray he does his best workPositive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
I contacted John T. Floyd Law firm and I was very satisfied with service extremely helpful and friendly thank you Mr. FloydPositive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More … More -
This law frim was informative,great response time ,and the attorney called back not some secretary or legal assistant thank u guys for all your help wish it was more like youPositive … More
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
I would highly recommend Mr Floyd. He was very helpful and knowledge with a legal question I had.Positive
Professionalism …More -
He explained my case better then any other lawyerPositive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
Very informative
-
-
-
-
Had the pleasure speaking with John Floyd on a personal matter, he was very responsive, nothing but exceptional, and he really cares about you with sincerity and most importantly knows … More what is he talking about! No games or bs, his approach to my situation even though I knew it was probably way smaller then what he normally takes on, he was extremely helpful and didn't care about the size of the matter like other attorneys do. He really looked out for my best interests. You can tell he has decades of experience doing what he does just by chatting with him. I would highly recommend him.
-
Words can’t describe how grateful I am for working with John, he went above and beyond my expectation. I was wrongly accused and hired many lawyers before hiring John Floyd but they … More all disappointed me, I had lost hope until a friend of mine referred me to John. From the start he had my best interest in mind and gave helpful advice, he explained the process and guided me. He put more work and time than all my previous lawyers that cost me thousands of dollars. He was constantly communicating with court and defended me more than all lawyer i had hired before him. Don’t waste your time and money like I did, believe me when I say I hired countless lawyers before him and no one came close to John. I’m forever thankful for him for fighting for my innocence and getting my case dismissed. Thank you so much🙏🏼🙏🏼
-
I called Mr Floyd and left a message, with in the hour I received a call back with much more information then I could have ever expected. Mr Floyd was very informative on every question … More I had for him. He seemed like he cared, instead of like most attorneys that you talk to that are just out for a quick buck. If you want someone that is going to shoot strait with you, and has your best interest in hand, this is you guy. This was the best experience that I have ever had with an lawyer.
-
I can state with confidence that Mr. Floyd and his team are the most competent and professional lawyers one can hope for. My case was quite complex and I admit that as a law student … More I was not the most patient client. Mr. Floyd did a phenomenal job of managing the bench, prosecution and myself! The result was above expectation, and I will never hesitate to recommend this firm regardless of the caliber of the case at issue.
-
It was a pleasure working with Mr. Floyd. I contacted him regarding a legal matter and he was extremely knowledgeable about the law, and responded in a timely manner. I appreciated … More the fact I did not feel rushed, and he made sure he thoroughly answered all questions I had. I would highly recommend him!Positive
Responsiveness, Professionalism …More -
Spoke with John Floyd about a 45 year old criminal case I was involved in. I had very little information about the case and John helped me search what records were available and gave … More me guidance to find more information. He was very professional and took his time helping me. I may need to hire a lawyer on this case and Mr. Floyd will be the man.Thanks John.
-
Very professional and straight forward. He's not going to waste your time or money. Very knowledgeable in a large range of possible matters one could face living in these days … More and times. If ever you need legal assistance, this is who I would suggest. Awesome!Positive
Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value …More -
I called about some legal questions I needed to get clarified and John was able to give me clarification and sound advice. I will definitely contact John for all future legal questions … More and issues.Thank you John!Positive
Responsiveness, Professionalism, Value …More -
Knows his stuff and well respected with DA and judges. I have referred him a couple times and every client has been satisfied
-
John is beyond knowledgeable! If I decide to pursue my case any further I would only have him represent me.
-
What a great attorney, this guy really took time out of his day to answer my questions and explain my case to me. Very grateful, thank you so muchPositive
Professionalism …More -
Absolutely a very professional lawyer. Very well read in the current law and more than willing to help if needed.
-
Mr. John he’s a professional he knows what he’s doing and he’s patient they recommend Him stronglyPositive
Professionalism …More -
Great service, very knowledgable and happy to help with any questions I had
-
Quick to action and helpful and knowledgeable with entertainment industry based issues!
-
Responded on a holiday week. Very knowledgeable and reassuring.
-
Very professional
-
-
-
-
I want to thank John T. Floyd and all of his team. He is the best lawyer who cares aboutHis clients and fights really hard to get the best outcome. He is a fighter and he is awesome!!!I … More recommend if any one needs criminal defense , he is the BEST. We had a really serious caseAnd we are very thankful for the outcome. Thank you John!!!!! God bless you!!!!!!
-
The attorneys at John T. Floyd Law Firm work diligently to achieve the best possible results for their clients. They are caring and knowledgeable professionals. Their expertise in the … More law and their experience as trial attorneys makes them the right choice as a defense attorney. I recommend this law firm highly.
-
From beginning to end this firm handled my case like the top tier professionals they are. I would not trust ANYONE else with my legal needs after having less than stellar experiences … More with other teams. Thank you Floyd!!!
-
I really felt like the team cared about my case and am super satisfied with the outcome. Would not recommend anyone else!
-
These guys do amazing work and have phenomenal service! Hands down best in the Houston area!!
-
John and Chris are true professionals! Love those guys like family!
-
Mr. Floyd and his team are very knowledgeable, informative, and helpful.
-
A team you can depend on to stand up and fight for you to prove the truth the whole truth!
-
-
Mr. John T. Floyd represented me.I couldn't be happier with the outcome he managed to achieve on an VERY Important case that was dismissed the day of Trial. He is patient & … More very knowledgeable of the legal system. I HIGHLY recommend him to anyone in need of a lawyer!John, I am forever grateful & satisfied with the effort you put forth & all you did for me. Thank you isn't enough!God bless you & your family!
-
The John T. Floyd Law Firm assisted me, and I can tell you that the attorney took the time to answer my questions, and I didn't feel rushed or dismissed as I have experienced in … More the past with attorneys. The attorney was very nice and extremely knowledgeable. Initial impressions and continued excellent customer service are big factors for me and as such I would highly recommend this firm.
-
I thank you for your efforts to help Felons regain their Civil rights, and for the information on possession , I am A convicted Felon, no violent history. I am an expert shot, I am … More 76 yoa, and very concerned about the present lake of Security in our State and Country. God Bless and Prosper you in your efforts, Your friend, Sonny Bivens
-
I really appreciated both Chris and John helping with my legal questions and concerns. Both are good guys and I would not hesitate to recommend them.
-
Extremely helpful!!! Helping me understand the law.
John T. Floyd is Board Certified in Criminal Law By the Texas Board of Legal Specialization
Request A Confidential Consultation
Fields marked with an * are required
"*" indicates required fields
Copyright © 2024 John T. Floyd Law Firm • All rights reserved.
Designed & Developed by
